How did Katie Die?
Katie was a fun-loving girl – who didn’t have the capacity to make any enemies. She was seeing a man called Brendan Harris – much against Jimmy’s will. The night she disappeared, she was out bar-hopping and enjoying the company of her friends. As the search begins, her car is soon discovered splattered with blood – giving strong signs of a violent attack. Katie’s dead body is found in the woods nearby – beaten and shot dead. She is recognized by Sean.
Why is Dave the prime suspect?
As a kid, Dave was abducted and raped for four days before managing to escape. The ghoulish incident left an indelible scar on his mind, and he is continually haunted by the horrifying memories. As a result, Dave’s personality and disposition were always ambiguous. On the night Katie is murdered, Dave was in the same bar as her. And he returns home bloodied and bruised. Upon being questioned by his wife, he tells her he got into a deadly scuffle with a robber – which his wife doesn’t believe.
Details obtained during the investigation
Sean, and his partner, Sergeant Whitey Powers, find out that the revolver used to shoot Katie was the same revolver that Brendan’s father used to conduct a robbery back in 1984. Certain that Katie’s murderer is either Dave or Brendan, Sergeant Whitey interrogates both men. Brendan’s responses are straightforward and seem true, while on the other hand, Dave appears nervous, quite uncomfortable, and fidgety- giving clear vibes of guilt of the crime. Sergeant Whitey is particularly suspicious of Dave as his account keeps changing in almost every inquiry.
What’s Jimmy’s Response?
After Dave’s wife, Celeste, expresses her fears about her husband being Katie’s killer, Jimmy decides to confront Dave himself. At a local bar, Jimmy meets with Dave along with his friends. Jimmy admits to killing Brendan’s father after he had to be incarcerated because of him. Dave tells Jimmy that he did commit a murder, but it wasn’t Katie. According to him, he killed a child molester the same night Katie died. Unconvinced about Dave’s account, Jimmy pulls out a knife and asks Dave to admit to his crimes. He offers to let him live if he tells the truth. One more time in an erratic manner, Dave changes his statement to take responsibility for Katie’s murder. Jimmy, without wasting a moment, kills Dave and dumps his body in the mystic river.
Was Dave really Katie’s murderer?
No, Dave didn’t have a thing to do with Katie’s case. Trying to find out the truth, Brendan questions his brother, Silent Ray, and his friend, John O’Shea, about his father’s missing gun. Realizing it was his brother who killed his girlfriend, Brendan frantically beats the two boys before O’Shea points a gun at him. Before he can fire, Sean and Sergeant Whitey arrive at the scene and arrest the two boys for the murder of Katie.
The Final Scene
Sean informs Jimmy that Silent Ray along with O’Shea confessed to killing his daughter. He also asks Jimmy about Dave – who he wants to help with a child molester murder case. At a complete loss for words, Jimmy doesn’t respond. He just thanks Sean for finding the killers of his daughter. In the last scene, Jimmy has his friends and family, Sean has reunited with his wife, but Dave’s son is alone looking for his father.
What does the ending mean?
The only question we need to tackle about Mystic River’s mind-bending ending is why Dave falsely admitted to killing Katie. Well, the logical explanation is that Dave’s mental trauma took every reason away from him to live. But, he carried on for his family against all odds. Dave knew Jimmy very well, he knew Jimmy wasn’t going to let his daughter’s killer live in any condition – even if he made a promise to do so. To conclude, it can be said Dave committed suicide – through Jimmy. He was fighting through every single moment in his life. And, when Jimmy pulled out the knife, the idea of embracing death got too tempting for him to let go.
Feel free to check out more of our movie reviews here!
